Skip to Content

10 Best Hotels in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

A guide to the best hotels in Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Tired of staying in the same old hotels while you travel? If so, check into one of these hotels in Sister Bay. 

From cozy cottages with lake views to luxury resorts with all the amenities, there is something here for every kind of traveler looking for a memorable stay. 

Get ready to explore the striking natural beauty and discover why travelers keep returning year after year while enjoying the best things to do in Door County!

a pin with one of the best hotels in Sister Bay, Wisconsin, seen from the exterior.

You, dear reader, support this blog. When you purchase through a link, I may earn a small commission. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Psssst…!!?? You can’t get enough of Wisconsin? Have a look at my other posts:

Top Hotels in Sister Bay

1. Coachlite Inn

living room with dining table, sofa and fire place at Coachlite Inn, Sister Bay, Wi

Looking for a charming and cozy hotel in Sister Bay, WI? The Coachlite Inn is a great choice.

This family-owned hotel offers 27 comfortable rooms that come equipped with all the amenities you could need, including air conditioning, microwaves, coffee and tea makers, and heating. 

And, perhaps best of all, your stay includes a free continental breakfast! 

The property also boasts a lovely garden complete with barbecue grills and a hot tub – the perfect way to unwind after a day spent exploring nearby Lake Michigan and Sister Bay Beach. 

Overall, the Coachlite Inn is the ideal spot for an authentic Door County getaway and one of the best resorts on Lake Michigan in Wisconsin. 

2. Sister Bay Inn

aerial view of the Sister Bay Inn in Wisconsin

I recently had the pleasure of staying at the Sister Bay Inn, known as one of the top Sister Bay resorts. 

The outdoor pool with sun loungers and barbecue grills was the perfect spot for enjoying the Wisconsin summer weather. 

Relaxing in the hot tub was another highlight of my stay. The free continental breakfast was a great way to start each morning of my vacation, and the terrace and firepit provided a cozy setting for evening gatherings with friends. 

Plus, being located near Pirate’s Cove Adventure Golf made it easy to enjoy some entertainment during my stay, making the hotel one of the best Wisconsin lake resorts for families. 

If you’re looking for a comfortable and convenient place to stay in Sister Bay, I highly recommend the Sister Bay Inn.

3. Country House Resort

best places to stay in Door County for couples, room with large king bed, whirlpool tub and balcony

As someone who loves to escape the chaos of city life, I can’t recommend the Country House Resort enough as one of the best places to stay in Sister Bay, WI. 

The lakefront hotel boasts an incredible terrace and garden with breathtaking views that make it easy to get lost in the beauty of nature. 

The seasonal outdoor pool with sun loungers is perfect for lounging after a long day of exploring, and the onsite activities like hiking, biking, rowing, canoeing, and volleyball make it easy to stay active and engaged in the outdoors. 

Not to mention, the library and a cozy fireplace in the lobby create a warm and inviting atmosphere that truly feels like home. 

The 46 rooms with premium bedding and air conditioning ensure a comfortable stay, while free bicycle rentals and an outdoor tennis court give you the opportunity to stay active and entertained. 

Trust me, the Country House Resort Sister Bay won’t disappoint, especially since there are so many things to do in Door County in winter.

4. The Inn at Little Sister Hill

secluded pool surrounded by forest at the The Inn at Little Sister Hill, Door County

There’s nothing quite like waking up at the Inn at Little Sister Hill and stepping out onto the terrace to take in the beautiful view of the lake. 

This lakefront hotel has everything you need for a relaxing and enjoyable stay, including a stunning garden, a seasonal outdoor pool with sun loungers, and plenty of onsite activities like hikes in Door County, biking, rowing, canoeing, and volleyball. 

If you’re looking for a cozy spot to curl up with a book, head to the library or gather around the fireplace in the lobby. 

For those looking to explore the area, the hotel offers free bicycle rentals and an outdoor tennis court. 

With 46 rooms featuring premium bedding and air conditioning, it’s no wonder the Inn at Little Sister Hill is often considered one of the best hotels in Sister Bay.

5. Church Hill Inn

bedroom at Church Hill Inn, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

I found one of the best resorts in Door County – the Church Hill Inn in Sister Bay. This charming resort boasts an English Pub-themed bar, a heated outdoor pool, and even a sauna for those looking to relax and unwind. 

With 34 elegant rooms to choose from, including family rooms and luxury suites, there is something for everyone. 

The romantic atmosphere sets the perfect tone for a weekend getaway or a special occasion. 

And to top it all off, guests can enjoy a refreshing dip in the pool and a complimentary breakfast in the morning. 

Overall, the Church Hill Inn is one of the best resorts in Sister Bay, WI that I highly recommend checking out.

6. Birchwood Lodge

aerial view of the Birchwood Lodge with beautiful green area in Sister Bay, Wi

I love staying at Birchwood Lodge Sister Bay, one of the best hotels in Door County. The free parking and beautiful views alone make it worth it, but there’s so much more to enjoy. 

On top of a refreshing pool, there’s a Fitness Center with Gym for those who like to stay active. For a unique way to explore the town, they even offer bicycle rentals. 

Plus, the children’s playground and badminton court mean there’s something for the whole family. 

I can’t wait to come back to Birchwood Lodge for my next trip to Sister Bay.

7. Pheasant Park

best resorts in Door County for failies, outside view of Pheasant Park Resort

I had the pleasure of staying at Pheasant Park during my recent trip to Sister Bay, WI and I have to say, it’s one of the best places to stay in the area. 

The seasonal outdoor pool was perfect for taking a dip on a hot summer day, while the indoor pool was great for a relaxing swim in the evenings. 

The fitness center was also a nice touch for those looking to stay active during their trip. When I needed to unwind, the garden was a beautiful retreat. 

The terrace overlooking the garden was a great spot to enjoy a cup of coffee in the morning or a glass of wine in the evening. 

If you’re in need of more relaxation, there is even a sauna on site. The rooms were top-notch with sprawling balconies, stunning views, and plenty of amenities like ping pong, hot tubs, and playgrounds. 

What’s more? Pheasant Park offers allergy-free rooms for those with sensitivities. 

I highly recommend this gem for anyone looking for comfort and entertainment during their stay in Sister Bay, WI. And while you’re here, go on and explore the best wineries in Door County.

8. Open Hearth Lodge

bedroom with 2 beds, an armchair and desk at Open Hearth Lodge, Door County

My recent stay at Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, WI was nothing short of wonderful! From the moment I stepped into the lobby, I was warmly greeted by the friendly staff. 

The free continental breakfast was a great way to start my day before heading out to explore the town. 

The sauna and hot tub were a luxurious addition to my stay. As a dog lover, I appreciated that some rooms were pet-friendly and even had a playground area for my furry friends to play in. 

No wonder it’s considered one of the best pet-friendly resorts in Wisconsin

The allergy-free rooms were a nice touch, ensuring that all guests could have a comfortable and enjoyable stay. 

The beautiful views and separate dining area in the family rooms were great features. The garden and barbecue grills were also a lovely amenity. 

I would definitely recommend Open Hearth Lodge to anyone looking for a pet-friendly hotel in Sister Bay!

9. The Nordic Lodge

best places to stay in Door County with pets, suite living room with sofa, recliner, coffee table, tv and fireplace

Last summer, my family and I took a much-needed break from the stresses of everyday life and booked a stay at one of the Sister Bay hotels with a pool – the Nordic Lodge. 

Tucked away in a peaceful location in the woods, the lodge provided the perfect retreat from the hustle and bustle of the city. 

I made sure to take advantage of the lodge’s indoor swimming pool and hot tub, which were the perfect way to unwind after a day of exploring the best things to do in Door County

One of the highlights of my stay was the daily continental breakfast, which had a variety of options to choose from. 

And for those who enjoy grilling, the BBQ facilities and garden were a pleasant surprise. 

My room had air conditioning, which was a welcome relief from the summer heat, and a lovely balcony where I could relax and enjoy the serene surroundings. 

I left feeling refreshed and rejuvenated, and now I can’t wait for my next adventure at the Nordic Lodge.

10. Waterbury Inn

living room with sofa and arm chairs at Waterbury Inn, Sister Bay, WI

As I arrived at the Waterbury Inn, I couldn’t help but feel impressed by its prime location next to one of the best lakes in Wisconsin, Lake Michigan. 

This lovely aparthotel is perfect for those seeking relaxation and comfort. One of the highlights of this place is the spa tub, ideal for enjoying a refreshing soak after a long day of exploring. 

And if you love pools like me, you’ll enjoy the indoor pool, outdoor pool, and fitness center. 

With 46 rooms to choose from, the Waterbury Inn has everything you need, including a fully equipped kitchen with amenities such as a refrigerator, stovetop, microwave, and dishwasher. 

It’s no wonder why this place is considered one of the best Sister Bay accommodations.

My final thoughts on the best hotels in Sister Bay

landscape in Sister Bay with a lake and forest where you can find the best Hotels in Sister Bay

Sister Bay possesses a special beauty found only in Door County. Its welcoming residents, lush environment, and abundant recreational opportunities make it a true paradise for visitors of all ages. 

With the perfect combination of modern amenities, outdoor recreation, and old-world charm, this idyllic getaway should be on everyone’s radar when considering a vacation destination. 

So make sure to add Sister Bay to your plans – you won’t regret it! 

A trip here should definitely include a stay at one of the many spectacular resorts where you can relax after a day of exploring all this destination has to offer. 

You won’t soon forget the amazing experiences you will have in this picturesque corner of Wisconsin. 

It’s time to discover why so many people keep coming back to Sister Bay year after year!

FAQ about the best hotels in Sister Bay

What are the best waterfront hotels in Sister Bay, WI?

Some of the best waterfront hotels in Sister Bay, WI are Pheasant Park, Country House Resort, or Coachlite Inn.

What are the best cheap hotels in Sister Bay, WI?

Some of the best cheap hotels in Sister Bay, WI are AppleCreek Resort, Sister Bay Inn, or Harbor Light Inn.

What are the best Sister Bay Resorts?

Some of the best Sister Bay resorts are Little Sister Resort, Country House Resort, or Pheasant Park.