Skip to Content

11 Unique Places To Stay In Door County

A guide to the most unique places to stay in Door County

Unique places to stay in Door County are perfect for anyone planning to travel Wisconsin. 

I recently visited the peninsula and was amazed by the variety of charming and quirky accommodations. 

My favorite part was finding a cozy waterfront home with a swimming pond that felt like a fairytale. 

Let me tell you about some incredible spots I found that made my trip unforgettable.

a pin with a dock and a lake cabin, unique places to stay in door county

You, dear reader, support this blog. When you purchase through a link, I may earn a small commission. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Psssst…!!?? You can’t get enough of Door County? Have a look at my other posts.

Unique villas to stay in Door County

1. Boutique Home in Door County with Eagle Harbor Views

living room with sofa and TV with big windows overlooking the lake at Boutique Home in Door County with Eagle Harbor Views

This Boutique Home in Door County with Eagle Harbor Views is one of the most unique places to stay in Door County. 

The three-bedroom, two-bathroom house sleeps eight and has a spacious 177 sq m layout, perfect for family or friends. 

I loved the cozy fireplace and the fully equipped kitchen, which made our stay feel like home. 

The back patio, complete with a barbecue grill, was ideal for al fresco dining while enjoying the stunning views of Eagle Harbor. 

Among the many cabins in Door County, this one stands out with its prime location across from Lake Michigan and Peninsula State Park. 

My stay was comfortable and fun, with nearby attractions like Wilson’s ice cream parlor and Anderson Dock Museum and Art Gallery.

2. Private and Luxury Family Compound

exterior of the Private and Luxury Family Compound in Door County, Wisconsin

This Private and Luxury Family Compound is one of the coolest places to stay in Door County. 

The 5-bedroom, 3+ bathroom house sleeps ten and offers 557 sq m pure luxury on five wooded acres. 

The gourmet kitchen was my favorite part, with top-of-the-line appliances and an expansive lawn perfect for lawn games. 

The pet-friendly cabin also has a hot tub, making it one of the best pet-friendly cabins in Door County. 

With a 70′ home theatre and stunning views from the main living area, it’s ideal for multi-generation family reunions or friends’ retreats. 

Being just a 2-minute drive from downtown Sister Bay and Ephraim, it was incredibly convenient for shopping and dining.

3. Exceptional Lake Michigan Waterfront cabin 

outdoor sitting area with table and chairs and lake view at Exceptional Lake Michigan Waterfront cabin in Door County, Wisconsin

This exceptional Lake Michigan waterfront cabin is one of the most fantastic places to stay in Door County on the water. 

With 4 bedrooms and 3+ bathrooms, it comfortably sleeps 12 and offers 390 sq m of luxurious space. 

The fully stocked kitchen and the cozy fireplace will make your evenings more special. 

The main living area on the second floor provides gorgeous views of the woods, sunrise, and sunsets. 

For anyone looking at Door County cabins on Lake Michigan, this spot is ideal for a getaway with friends.

The lower-level home theatre and outdoor space with a barbecue grill were perfect for our group.

4. Beautiful Waterfront Home With Swimming Pond

boat in front of the Beautiful Waterfront Home With Swimming Pond in Door County, Wisconsin

Located along the tranquil shores of Door County, this waterfront home offers everything you need for a perfect family getaway. 

The spacious layout with 5 bedrooms and 2+ bathrooms comfortably accommodated our group 15, making it an ideal gathering spot. 

Of course, I took advantage of the fully-equipped kitchen and prepared delicious foods that made me feel at home, and the gas fireplace added to the cozy ambiance of our stay. 

Outside, the swimming pond, complete with a beach and fire pit, provided endless entertainment for kids and adults.

We loved the convenience of having a barbecue grill and a 185′ boat dock right by the bay, perfect for soaking in the stunning views and enjoying outdoor meals. 

This beautiful waterfront home ticks all the boxes when it comes to places to stay in Door County with a pool and it’s part of the Door County cabins on the lake collection, so you know the setting is stunning. 

5. Gray Gull Cottage

porch with sitting table and lake view at Gray Gull Cottage in Door County, Wisconsin

Watching sunsets over Green Bay from the Gray Gull Cottage was indeed an unforgettable experience and it’s part of my list of places where to stay in Green Bay.

This 3-bedroom, pet-friendly retreat is on a wooded acre and offers a serene escape just 6 miles south of Egg Harbor. 

The screened porch was perfect for summer meals with a view, and I loved relaxing on the cobblestone beach by the fire pit. 

The cathedral ceiling in the living room and the cozy fireplace created such a warm atmosphere, especially after a day of cross-country skiing. 

This Gray Gull Cottage is a fantastic option for those looking for places to stay in Door County that allow dogs or for the best Airbnbs in Door County.

6. Family Friendly Retreat in the Heart of Sister Bay

cozy living room with blue sofas at the Family Friendly Retreat in the Heart of Sister Bay, Wisconsin

The Family Friendly Retreat in the Heart of Sister Bay offers a cozy escape with a touch of Swedish charm right on Bay Shore Drive. 

As I’m an active person, I took many walks along the beach and explored the town with its lovely restaurants and coffee shops. 

The front deck was a fantastic spot to relax with a book or just enjoy Sister Bay’s lively atmosphere. 

If you don’t know where to stay in Door County for families, this is a good start as it’s one of the unique places to stay in Door County that will allow you to have a perfect time together. 

Its pet-friendly options and comfortable amenities made my stay incredibly enjoyable.

7. Lake Michigan house with Sand Beach 

Lake Michigan house with Sand Beach in Door County, Wisconsin seen from the beach

The Lake Michigan house in Jacksonport offers a fantastic getaway with its sandy beach and scenic views. 

I had such a great time relaxing by the water and enjoying the home’s spacious layout. With three bedrooms and three bathrooms, there was plenty of room for everyone, and the well-stocked kitchen made meals a breeze. 

It’s one of the cabins to rent in Door County that offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. 

Whether you’re lounging on the beach or exploring nearby Sturgeon Bay, this spot is hard to beat for a peaceful retreat.

8. Door County’s Chalet On The Shore

the Door County's Chalet On The Shore in Wisconsin seen from the lake at sunset

Right on the shoreline of Sturgeon Bay, this lakefront Chalet is perfect for a memorable family getaway. 

The space feels cozy and expansive with its cathedral ceilings and open-concept living area. 

I enjoyed the stunning bay views from the large deck, where we gathered in the evenings around the gas fire pit table. 

The upstairs loft, with a king bed and en suite bathroom, is great for a quiet retreat, while the main floor bedrooms and the Queen Sleeper Sofa comfortably accommodate everyone. 

If you’re exploring the best things to do in Door County, this spot offers easy access and many amenities. 

The Door County’s Chalet by the shore is truly the best place to stay in Door County, with its private pier, lawn games, and ample outdoor space for fun and relaxation.

9. Beachfront Cottage with Rustic Charm 

Beachfront Cottage with Rustic Charm in Door County at sunset

A stay at this cottage along Sturgeon Bay is like stepping back in time with a modern twist. I was blown away by the stunning sunsets we enjoyed from the Adirondack chairs or the wrap-around screened porch. 

The cozy great room with its wood-burning fireplace made for perfect evenings after exploring the Unique Places To Stay In Door County. 

I was so happy having 200 feet of private shoreline to relax on and the chance to take out the 15′ rowboat for some peaceful time on the water. 

If you’re looking at Lakefront Cabins For Rent In Wisconsin, this place offers a beautiful mix of history, comfort, and fantastic views. 

The large outdoor deck and fire pit were great for gathering with friends and family at this beachfront rustic cottage.

10. Shoreline Retreat on Lake Michigan

colorful living room with great views at Shoreline Retreat on Lake Michigan in Door County, Wisconsin

Wake up to spectacular sunrises at this charming Lake Michigan retreat. I enjoyed the walkable beach and cozied up by the stone fireplace in the evening. 

If you’re searching for where to stay on Lake Michigan, this spot perfectly blends rustic charm with modern amenities. 

The master bedroom’s king-size bed and business-class WiFi made for a super comfortable stay, and the large sectional couch and 50″ Smart TV were perfect for relaxing after exploring nearby towns like Jacksonport. 

With a flagstone patio, Weber gas grill, and a fire pit for the evenings, this is an ideal spot for a lakeside getaway. 

Having the beach right at my doorstep and exploring local spots like Mike Port Pub and Town Hall Bakery was perfect for me. 

11. Charming Ellison Bay house close to Europe Lake

Charming Ellison Bay house close to Europe Lake in Door County, Wisconsin

This house near Europe Lake offers a perfect blend of comfort and charm for a Door County getaway. 

You will enjoy the cozy feel of the covered front porch and the spacious living areas inside. 

For cool cabins in Wisconsin and unique places to stay in Door County, this spot is fantastic with its traditional decor and family-friendly features. 

The small raspberry garden was a delightful surprise, and the fire pit circle was great for starry nights. Everything around the house looks like a fairytale.

The Starlink internet made staying connected while enjoying the serene surroundings easy.

My final thoughts on Unique Places To Stay In Door County

sitting table with chairs with lake views in front of one of the unique places to stay in door county

Finding unique places to stay in Door County has been a delightful experience. Each location, with its distinct charm, truly offers something for everyone. 

I’m all about discovering cozy cabins and quirky inns that feel like a home away from home. You have to check out these special spots next time you plan a trip. 

Door County’s lodging options add an unforgettable touch to any getaway.

FAQ about Unique Places To Stay In Door County

What are the most unique places for couples to stay in Door County?

Some of the most unique places to stay in Door County for couples are the White Gull Inn, the Charming Ellison Bay house close to Europe Lake, or the Chalet on the Shore in Sturgeon Bay.

What are the best places to stay in Door County?

Some of the best places to stay in Door County are Bridgeport Waterfront Resort, Shoreline Retreat on Lake Michigan, and Chanticleer Guest House.

What are the best Door County hotels on the water?

Some of the best Door County hotels on the water are Glidden Lodge Beach Resort, Bay Breeze Resort, and the Lake Michigan House with Sand Beach.